Note: Trends can be a useful pointer to Cheltenham winners but it’s important to consider all stats in context. Always consider the difference between correlation and causality.
SHISHKIN – SUPREME NOVICE HURDLE
Trend(s): The past 11 winners had run at least 4 times over hurdles. Only 1 of the last 11 winners had no previous graded form.
A total of 177 horses have lined up for the Supreme in the last 11 renewals. Of those, 95 (54%) had less than 4 previous runs over hurdles – none of which have managed to win.
Just 1 of the front 6 in both the 2018 & 2019 renewals had less than 4 runs over hurdles; they made up 46% of the runners and it’s not as if they were unfancied – Getabird was the 7/4 favourite back in 2018, eventually finishing 11th.
Therefore, it must be a concern to Shishkin supporters that he’s only raced 3 times over timber (and he didn’t get past the 2nd obstacle on his first run) while fellow market leader, Asterion Forlonge, has only had two starts over hurdles.
On the other hand, Abacadabras & Fiddlerontheroof boast experience and graded form.
This does not mean that the Donnely duo can’t win but it is certainly something to bear in mind when assessing the festival opener.
CAREFULLY SELECTED – NATIONAL HUNT CHASE
Trend: Only 1 winner in the last 10 years had 3 (or less) chase stars prior to contesting this race
Since becoming a level-weights contest in 2010, the National Hunt chase has been a happy hunting ground for relatively experienced novices. Heading into this race, the last 10 winners had an average of 7.1 starts over fences. The exact breakdown of prior runs over fences is as follows: 11,9,5,3,4,10,4,10,10,5. It’s no surprise that experience comes to the fore here given the questions this race poses to a novice and I doubt the two-furlong reduction in distance will change that.
This trend didn’t stop the ill-fated Ballyward going off as favourite for last year’s renewal. He and OK Corral, who was the 2nd favourite, only had 2 chase starts to their name; both failed to complete.
However, supporters of Carefully Selected will be encouraged by 2013 winner, Back in Focus. Also trained by Willie Mullins, he had just 3 chase starts prior to his win at Cheltenham. In fact, he only had 6 starts under rules so it is possible for an inexperienced horse to win. He did already have a grade 2 and a grade 1 win over fences to his name so his class was undeniable.
Carefully Selected has won two grade 3’s over fences, finished 2nd in the 2018 Champion Bumper and this race has been the target for some time.
But it’s hard not to be concerned by his lack of experience (just three chase starts) and his questionable jumping. I’m keen to take him on.
GREANETEEN – GRAND ANNUAL
Trend: All 119 runners in the last 15 renewals to have won a handicap chase earlier in the season were beaten (That fantastic snippet comes from Matt Tombs @thespieler)
It’s rare for a Grand Annual winner to have a ‘1’ in their recent form figures. In the 2-mile handicap chase division, it’s common for horses to come right in the Spring, leaving behind a trail of disappointing runs earlier in the season.
Greaneteen is a perfect 3/3 over fences, including two handicap victories (one novice handicap and one in open company). Those performances have resulted in him going up 16lbs in the handicap to a mark of 150.
Just two winners in the last ten years had won a race earlier in the season before lining up here. They were Bellvano (2012) & Alderwood (2013). The positive for Greaneteen supporters is that they were also novices. However, they had only won in novice company which will encourage supporters of Lisp and Chosen Mate.
This trend also calls into question the credentials of many other fancied runners: Éclair De Beaufeu, Magic Saint, On The Slopes and Capeland also carry the burden of previous handicap success.
AL BOUM PHOTO – GOLD CUP
Trend: There hasn’t been a back-to-back winner of the Gold Cup since Best Mate completed the hat-trick (2002-2004);
I decided to include this one as it’s bound to be mentioned in countless preview evenings up and down the land. Of the 4 trends I’ve highlighted in this piece, I believe this one has the least credence behind it. Let’s discuss.
Since Best Mate, there has only been eight attempts to defend the crown in the fifteen subsequent renewals; perhaps that’s partly down to the toll that winning a Gold Cup takes on a horse.
The record of those eight is: 22FP35P4 – It’s not surprising that Kauto Star, Denman & Long Run went the closest to winning 2 on the bounce. Of those that completed, only Bobs Worth (5th) failed to finish in the top 4.
We’re dealing with a very small sample size here and it would be hasty to dismiss the claims of the reigning champion based on this information.
I believe that Al Boum Photo has an outstanding chance of winning the Gold Cup again; he hasn’t been overly raced throughout in his career (just 15 starts under rules) and he’s mirrored last year’s successful preparation; Henrietta Knight’s light handling of Best Mate ensured his longevity and it’s very encouraging that Willie is taking a similar approach.
He looked as good as ever when winning the Savills Chase on New Year’s Day and he looks to have a great chance of completing the double.